In my first post about the attack from the Great Firewall of China, I stuck to the facts. There was a simple reason for this: you don’t want conjecture when your site is down. You want to understand the problem and see suggestions on how to fix it.
This post will be different: these are my opinions and they are pointed. I’ll first note some of the reactions I received, then examine some of the technical subtleties, and conclude with speculation on the motives behind the attack.
By time you finish, you’ll also understand the odd title for this post.
Reactions from China
Luckily, the server that provided the page you’re reading now was not attacked. I have purposefully not blocked any Chinese IP addresses at furbo.org. I wanted people there to see what their government is doing from a western perspective.
It’s hard to say how many people in China saw the post, but I do know that some have (at one point I saw twelve visitors from Beijing.) What I found most interesting was that every single person who contacted me used the same word to express their thoughts: “shame.”
Clearly, this attack was not an intentional act by the people of China. No one approves of what their government is doing. I can empathize with this shame: I’d feel the same way if a malicious third party made my browsing ruin the day of a random site owner. Grass Mud Horse!
What happened on my server was not an isolated incident. I have seen many other developers saying “me too!” in the past few days.
I suspected this was the case, but wondered why there wasn’t more discussion about what was happening. I’m guessing that when you’re fighting a fire, there’s little time to discuss the intricacies of how the fricken’ flamethrower is melting the fricken’ network interface.
Some of the discussion came from people who know a lot more about running servers than I do. The most telling was from John Adams:
This is happening, and happening to a number of the sites I manage. What the fuck, China? http://t.co/vPGON0QSgR
— John Adams (@netik) January 23, 2015
Look at his bio: he was one of the engineers that designed Twitter’s infrastructure. If a professional like John is saying “WTF?”, amateurs like me are pretty much screwed. Grass Mud Horse!
Another notable post was from Jamie Zawinski, one of the first people to write a web browser. I was hopeful that his clever response to the Chinese BitTorrent traffic would eventually make it go away.
Unfortunately, it appears there is nothing you can do to quiet the BitTorrent clients. I don’t know enough about this technology to offer any guidance, but someone sure as hell needs to look at the problem and deploy fixes across millions of machines in China. Unless, of course, the Chinese government decides to block BitTorrent client downloads.
The TorrentFreak website has a great overview of BitTorrent’s role in these attacks.
And now would be a good time to pray to your favorite deity that your IP address doesn’t show up here. Note that test is just against our friend “thepiratebay.org”. Your server’s IP address could show up for any other popular site on the web.
That, folks, is DNS poisoning in action. Grass Mud Horse!
False Sense of Security
Even with packet filtering in place, I still feel vulnerable. Why?
I’m not sure the blocks will withstand another 52 Mbps flood. Remember that up to 65,535 filter rules can be matched by code in the kernel. Your ability to block packets is only as good as the CPU that’s running that code. When I hear that dedicated Cisco firewall hardware is failing, it give me no confidence that my box with 6,500 rules getting 13,000 packets per second will be able to keep up. A back of the envelope calculation shows 84.5 million comparisons per second is needed (or one every 11 nanoseconds.)
For this same reason, don’t assume that any routers or load balancing schemes upstream from your server will be able to keep up with China. There’s no guarantee that your hosting provider will be able to protect your servers or VM instances at rates like we experienced last week.
Still don’t believe me? Look at the first comment on this post at the Internet Storm Center:
I had the same problem starting last Friday, the 2nd. Took out a full load balanced cluster of servers.
Grass Mud Horse!
The biggest unanswered question is why did this happen to the Iconfactory? (Apologies to visitors from China: you won’t be able to look at that link. Grass Mud Horse!)
Our only connection to China is that one of the partners, Talos Tsui, was born and raised in Hong Kong (during the years it was a Crown colony.) It seems unlikely that we’ve done anything to piss off the Chinese government. At least until just now…
The traffic spikes earlier in the week lead me to think that we were being randomly tested for our ability to handle a large volume of traffic. We have fat pipes without automatic DDoS protection. The duration and volume of the probes could determine both of those attributes.
The Chinese government is not only being deceitful with IP addresses, they’ve also begun cracking down on a mechanism that lets its citizens avoid the bullshit: VPN. Grass Mud Horse!
This action, combined with the DDoS floods, is beneficial to a government that’s intent on isolating its citizens from the free and open Internet. They make it hard to get a packet out of China, but even if you succeed, it’s likely to be blocked by a server that’s been victim of their DDoS.
On the surface, this seems like a good strategy for creating your own private Internet: a network where no packets can enter the west or leave the east.
There is Hope
The Internet was designed to route around damage. While the ability to withstand a nuclear war is a myth, the protocols we use every day were created to be robust against infrastructure loss. Even when that section of the network is the size of China.
But even more important than the technology is the people who use the Internet.
From a personal perspective, the DDoS attack from China made me acutely aware of how screwed up things are over there. The government’s actions have pissed me off and I’ll now do anything in my power to thwart their efforts. Like writing this piece.
And given the feedback I’ve received, I’m not alone with this point-of-view. People are fighting back. I’m hopeful that over the course of several years, we’ll find better ways to cope with the idiocy of the Chinese government than to tunnel under their firewall and block their IP addresses.
If you doubt people’s ingenuity in routing around roadblocks, take a moment to learn about the Grass Mud Horse:
(The whole video is informative, but be sure to watch the end.)